Pros And Cons Of Iron Vs Aluminum Engine Blocks

When it comes to engine blocks, the debate between which material is the toughest, most durable, and most convenient seems endless. Some folks argue that aluminum engine blocks lead to better car performance. Others say that iron supports high power better than the aluminum build.

Until a few decades ago, iron was the ultimate engine block material. A large percentage of cars produced from the mid-’90s pack an aluminum engine block under the hood.

Aluminum alloy metals continue to gain popularity in the market. Aluminum blocks have already made their way into popular cars. These include the Ferrari F12 Berlinetta and Audi R8, among many others. And chances are, your car has an aluminum block, or at the very least, aluminum internal components.

Before we get down to comparing the two, let’s understand an engine block. An engine block is the entire structure of the engine. The block supports all the inside components. This includes the cylinders, oil galleries, and coolant passages, and many more. So, the engine block is the foundation for the whole internal combustion engine. Aside from housing internal components, the engine block also transfers heat from friction to the engine coolant. But of course, the block material is a vital consideration if you want to get the best from your engine. Since each material has it share of upsides and downsides, you want to find one that retains more advantages. One that’s set to give you better performance, with lesser problems in the long run. So, in the end, a good engine starts from a good engine block.


Both engine types have some pros and cons worth considering. Whether you want to perform a swap and are researching sick engines to buy or just want to learn more about engines in general, you’ll want to know the difference between iron and aluminum blocks. We’ll discuss the advantages and drawbacks of iron and aluminum block engines, focusing on their strength, weight, power, cost, repairability, and durability.

Iron Block: Pros And Cons


chevy-big-m-engine-block-grey-cast
Via: Kindpng

Iron blocks have been around since the birth of the engine. Up to this very day, the iron block material is a standard choice to engine manufacturers.

Pros

First of all, iron blocks are cheaper than aluminum blocks. On average, a pound of aluminum costs $1 while a pound of iron only costs 25 cents. That said, it’s easy to accept that the use of iron will reduce production costs, making it more appealing.

The reason why iron is the standard material is due to its durability. An iron engine block is stronger and more durable than an aluminum block. It can also withstand higher pressures than its aluminum counterpart.

Another advantage you’ll find with an iron engine block is power. Due to its massive strength, the iron block can handle more power and boost than an aluminum one. These days, aluminum blocks are capable of handling as much power as the latter. But, an aluminum block tends to suffer than an iron block, especially at lower thresholds.

Cons

One major disadvantage that comes with iron engine blocks is that they are susceptible to rusting. Since the iron block makes more power, it likely undergoes a lot of pressure. So, rusting is a major factor and something that’s inevitable since you’re dealing with metal. Also, iron blocks are heavier than aluminum blocks. This extra weight can affect the car’s performance and fuel economy.

When it comes to repairing, it’s much harder to repair an iron block than an aluminum one. Indeed, the iron block costs less. But when components of the iron engine block need repairing, it can cost you as much as a new block. It’s easier to replace an iron block than it is to repair it.

RELATED: 10 Of The Most Reliable V8 Engines Ever

Aluminum Block: Pros And Cons


aluminum-engine-block-white-background
Via: alibaba.com

Aluminum engine blocks are very popular alternatives to the longest-staying iron blocks.

Pros

Most folks go for aluminum engine blocks because they are easier to repair than iron blocks. As we stated earlier, repairing an iron block is a challenge that’s not worth the effort. But, aluminum engine blocks are simpler to fix. A solid aluminum block is the one in the Camaro ZL1.

Aluminum engine blocks are lighter in weight than their iron counterparts. Aluminum weighs half as much as iron. Weight reduction has been a milestone for automakers for ages. This is common in the sports segment. So, the aluminum engine blocks make a desirable option. Less engine weight gives you better gas mileage. It also makes the car lighter, leading to greater acceleration and speed.

Aluminum blocks handle heat better than iron blocks. As such, an aluminum engine block is less likely to experience overheating. This improves the engine’s life.

Cons

Aluminum engine blocks are more prone to warping, especially when under pressure. This is because they aren’t as rigid as iron cast blocks.

Also, aluminum blocks are costly, which makes them expensive to produce. On the consumer’s end, it elevates the car’s price.

One more important aspect to consider is that aluminum blocks produce less power.

RELATED: These 10 Small Cars Are Packing Some Serious Engines

What Is The Best Engine Block Material?


aluminum-engine
Via: Pexels/Pixabay

The best engine block is cast iron. Today, the Ford Coyote for drag racers is a solid option. Its more durable, cheap, and higher power rating than the aluminum engine block. The major downfalls are the rust, the added weight, and the repairability, or lack thereof. This doesn’t make the aluminum counterparts any less desirable. They are lighter, easier to repair, and less susceptible to overheating. But aluminum engine blocks are less strong, more prone to warping, and pricier. Under the right conditions, an aluminum block can produce as much power as an Iron block. Engine makers are working to make the aluminum engine more rigid. But for now, iron cast blocks are your safest bet.



Boss 302 Engine
How Muscle Car Enthusiasts Can Find The Right Engine On eBay Motors

The right engine for your muscle car makes all the difference.

Read Next


About The Author

https://www.hotcars.com/pros-and-cons-of-iron-vs-aluminum-engine-blocks/

Nina Zatulini

Next Post

5 Inexpensive Ways to Extend the Life of Your Car

Thu Dec 30 , 2021
The car has around 111,000 miles on it, and Fleury’s father is responsible for about 13,000 of those. Fleury has taken responsibility for maintaining the car and keeping this gift on the road. “Treating an old vehicle with respect — not viewing it as a ‘beater’ and simply performing routine […]